Showing posts with label MnD. Show all posts
Showing posts with label MnD. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 27, 2016

MnD - Deep thinking about the game (2015/01/25)

I have been thinking about the value of the game. Why am I addicted to the game for almost half an year? (Don't get it wrong. I am still enjoying the strategic choice we can make in the game =) )

First, the scale of the battle is massive. Almost over 900 units fighting in the battlefield at the same time, each with their own HP, defence and target to attack. In terms of coding involved, it should be rather massive.

Second, there are many combinations of rallies. Heroes skills are uniquely designed (among 4 stars). It is quite fun to think about a better rally when new heroes are released.

Thirdly, it is a PvP game. Competition is always an element that spices things up.

But, what is missing in the game?

One, there are not much interactions to players during the fight. Morale skills, which are limited, are the only thing we can do.  Surely that limits the fun (it is like watching a TV show during a battle).

Two, it is quite hard to try new things out. Leveling up heroes are quite hard in the game. And that demotivates me to try them out. While some heroes are OP (Reinhard, Polymage), they become a must-use once u have it. Not much thinking involved...(who arent using 5+1 in v1.8.5?)

Three...the most important part.  The game is very repeatative. It really needs some randomness (like environment hazards) so to get players attention without violating the game's principe: limited players' intervention to the battle

Monday, December 28, 2015

MnD - New gears (2015/12/27)

New tcrystal fears for Christmad, including a helm and a ring.
Compared to Hades gears, the Christmas ring has 2000 hp more and slightly higher defense, but less attack power (not significant tho). Generally a good ring for tanks (still no dodge for rings...)

The helm is kind of similar to Hades helm but slightly more aggressive (more attack power but less defense and Hp). A fair helm i would say.
But the key is the bonus gears when you purchase tcrystals...they are quite strong, especially the weapon...that damage and dodge tho.
 

Wednesday, December 9, 2015

MnD - Buff on Edward (2015/12/09)

Thanks for all your love to the blogger. This really give me motivation to go on =]

This time it is about one of my favourite heroes, Edward. He has been buffed in v1.9 significantly. Let's see what he is up to:

1. Duration of stun at level 11 and 12 increases to 8s and 10s respectively
2. Heavy musketeers do 100% bonus attack to stunned units
3. A proc rate necklace can increase the proc rate of hero skills should it be an active one

No need to do any math. You can already see the buff to Edward (6s cooldown, 60% proc rate with the necklace on. Some enemies will be stun-locked to death).

Some more things that might spice things a little bit more - the release of advanced savage unit for Canon. One of the advanced type can stun and reduce the defense of the stunned unit. So...I see a huge potential with Edward with Canon, as well as the infantry who can stun enemies.

Hopefully this can bring back part of the glorious days of musketeers.

Tuesday, December 1, 2015

MnD - More new necklaces for v1.9 (2015/12/01)

The official release note for v1.9 is out. You can check it out yourself. Inwill try cover them in tthe coming posts. (This post is supposingly release 2 days ago but I forgot to publish it...)

My lord, what have you done to the new necklaces...

Gladiator's Glory:
Increase the damage of hero by 25%, and have a 30% chance to instant kill a non-hero unit.
Comment: My god. Imagine a Reinhard that is un-killable and can kill your minions. This item also works great with DPS heroes like Hedvig. But for heroes who rely on crits, Curse Necklace might be slightly better.

Orge Peral: Hero skill will crit and deal 15% bonus damage
Comments: This one sounds great but the same issue as Commander Necklace. This is a by-chance increase in damage. If you are unlucky like me, you might not even have a crit in the entire battle. Otherwise, this should greatly fit for casters, especially Edward (who is greatly buffed is this release)

Ancient Elf Courage: When a hero casts skill, troops and hero will get a 20% damage increase for 3s.
Comments: It seems great at first, but my second thought is that this is for mages and musketeers majnly. Pikemen have skills that only cast once in the battle so it is useless on them. Well, musketeers arent that strong now (but triniti is spending efforts to buff musketeers as u will see in the release note in triniti forum. I will cover more details layer) so we will see how this necklace works.

The healing bonus necklace is not mentioned in the release. Likely it is removed. The slience and proc rate necklace are still there.


Sunday, November 22, 2015

MnD - Charles (2015/11/22)

Out of boredom, I made this to show my respect to Charles Martel and his family.


Hope that they will be released in v1.10.

(I am totally not complain the reuse of the heroes or something. But they just look the same LOL)

Saturday, November 14, 2015

MnD - 5+1 Rally (2015/11/13)

One of the most common rally since v1.8 is the 5+1 rally. It composites of a max skill Reinhard alone in the top-most lane (the 1) and the bottom 5 lanes filled with what ever you have.
A reference of 5+1 (ignore the 5, i just made one up for illustration)

Since v1.8, Reinhard has more than 10s invincibility and very good at tanking 3-4 squad by himself. You only need to drop one mist on him at the beginning of the battle and he will stall the enemies for a good amount of tine without your attention.

One extremely important element of 5+1 is you must have Phil, and he must be next to Reinhard so Reinhard can stay alive way longer.

Since everyone is using 5+1 (most of the players), this becomes a "do it or lose" rally formation (i feel like it). If more people are having the 1 at the top, others have to follow or you will send your 5 against the 1, which is an absolutely waste of firepower.

Of course, there are many ways to counter Reinhard. If Reinhard is dead very early, 5+1 is rather useless:
  1. Polymorph to disable Reinhard's in casting his skill
  2. Morgana to silence Reinhard
  3. Hedvig to length Reinhard's cooldown
  4. Burst down Reinhard with the OP Lancelot (in case you dunno, there is a bug that Lancelot has 100% chance to cast his skill, as soon as his skill is not in cooldown)
Some elements of the "Top-Shield" reused, particularly pikeman at top left

And this was the way I used Reinhard (with a pikeman at the back), which I think is better than 5+1 as the cavalry won't attack Reinhard if there are too many units already in fight with Reinhard. This formation is to counter cavalry-heavy rally.

Monday, October 26, 2015

MnD - Partner in Crime (2015/10/26)

15 minutes before another call. Lemme quickly make the post for today.

There are heroes who are partner in crime. Without each others they are like nothing. Wanna make some counting here. Of cuz welcome to add your recommended to the list!

  1. Reinhard and Phil.: The infamous tank combo who can disable at least 3 rallies if positioned well. Reinhard can be invincible for roughly 11s and Phil can heal Reinhard when he is invincible. It has given a lot of people a tough time in offensive PvP. I use it, and i hate it as well.
  2. 3 MAs: Nicola and his 3* MA brothers can do tones of damage from far. With lv12 skill, they can be quite annoying to fight against. But they do not do so good when at higher PL.
  3. Polymages array: with 2 or more polymages, they can contain 30units constantly. The enemy can do almost nothing to protect troops against polymages.
Okay, times up. I have way many ideas but...haha

Sunday, October 25, 2015

MnD - Good heroes in v1.8.5 (2015/10/25)

What heroes are good in this version, who were not?

  1. Terim: His mechanical dragon is very strong at creating distruption to enemies' backline. Although musketeers are nerfed badly, his skill worths a lot
  2. Lancelot: His heal applies to his troops too, so he is more tanky than ever. Not to mention that he is with a bug that he has 100% proc rate in this version (and I am surprised that Triniti is not going to fix this ASAP)
  3. Hilda: Her skill targets the hero with highest damage in her range. She can be potent against physical damage heroes like Leondias
  4. 3* Polymages: Not many counters available against their skills, which have the max. sheep number increased at max skill level
And who are the heroes that...you don't know if they are good unless the community develops him / her?
  1. Mary Read: AoE slow. I have no idea how that can be useful as her skill is not instant (won't hit fast units, and slow units do not care)
  2. Rengar: After the buff, he might be a little bit stronger, but not very strong (e.g. 1 Hilda can counter him perfectly)
And...I want to see arbalists coming back to the field. They were strong tanks (like Kelly). Now with Assassin, the first line should have their places, at least i think.

Sunday, October 11, 2015

MnD - Hero Restraint? (2015/10/11)

Here is a little thinking about he new restraint system (aka weapon and armor system):

Minions are under this new system that each weapon type can or may do better against certain types of armor. How about heroes?

It was a rumor that heroes are under the old restraint system (e.g. Pikeman hero does 1.5x damage against Cavalry hero, and Sarky does 1.33x damage against all heroes)

Now, i dont think so. One key indicator is...hero does not have an indication of their armor type and weapon type. You might say, their type should follow their minions. I doubted, as the weapon and armor type of minions change when they "evolve" (becoming advanced units). I dont think upgrading minions change the hero as well (or else some evolution will be way better than the others)

This is not scientifically proved tho (I dont have my phone now unfortunately). Just my opinion..

Monday, October 5, 2015

MnD - Does sheep dodge? (2015/10/04)

Polymorph disables affected units to act and turns their defense to 0. Act, from what we can see in the game, includes moving and attacking. But, is dodge disabled as well?

(This is a preliminary test only)

When unit dodges in mist, a "Missed" display will be shown.
Alash and his troops with 100% dodging rate in mist, showing "Miss" as indication

But, what if a mist is casted on top of polymorphed units?
Here Shazzo is polymorphed. Still, "Miss" indicator were displaying, meaning that they were dodging in polymorphed form. If polymorphed can remove dodge, it will be way too strong and deserve a nerf very soon.

PS: In previous version, sheeps can dodge in mist. That was a known bug which has been fixed by triniti in this version.

Thursday, October 1, 2015

MnD - New necklace (2015/09/30)

In the coming few days, we can fight in Authur's special stage to get a series of new necklaces, the Dark Necklace and Depravity Necklace.
       
The necklace improves physical defense for a little bit. If the minion of the hero with this necklace die, the hero is healed by a certain % (max 4%) of max health of the dead minion.

Assume each minion has 5000 HP, a rally of 25 minions heal the 4% necklace wearer for 5000*25*4%=5000 HP (exactly one minion's max health)

So is this good?

This is obviously a necklace for frontline tanks, especially pavisers as their minions have more health than other classes.

Best defense stat (70 def) reduces 28 physical damage per hit. Not fancy at all.

The healing is at least certain (unlike Arcane Apprentice), although it is not really attractive in my opinion. Shadow Necklace heals 120 HP per second and also increases max HP for 1000. Assume 2 minutes fight, the hero gets heal by 14,400 HP with an additional of 1000 HP. You see the difference?
Triniti might have to buff the %max health return in order to make this practical. You know, 120 energy for a necklace ain't cheap.

Tuesday, September 29, 2015

MnD - 1st Advanced Unit (2015/09/28)

Heroes above lv50 can choose to promote his or her units to 1st advanced units that look different than the basic ones and are almost stronger in terms of HP, damage and defense.

Here is a summary of changes of unit stats after promotion @lv176:
  • Infantry has the greatest improvement in almost every aspect except defense growth per level
  • Paviser has less HP and HP growth per level after promotion
  • Musketeer has the least improvement in every aspect (w/o considering -ve growth)
Infantry is definitely a big heat in this version. I expect heroes like Helmar, Joan and William will return to the battle field.

And...for science, 2 commander badges are sacrificed to record these figures.

Monday, September 28, 2015

MnD - AoE target number confirmed! (2015/09/28)

Haah, myth confirmed on the number of AoE targets. It's 15!
Is Sam watching this blog so he decided to add more info to the skills? LOL

Saturday, September 5, 2015

MnD - Urza and Jerome, best partner in crime? (2015/09/05)

Urza, the pikeman hero that everyone will eventually own. His skill is as follow:
With Jerome's Redemption, will he be able to cast his spell again? (so Jerome revives a 2-up Urza?)

Let's give this a very simple test, just put Jerome and Urza in the rally and send them to their death until a result is obtained. After sacrifacing 6 Jerome and :
Jerome is able to revive Urza mutiple times but Urza only casts once (his 1st death).

So, Urza does not have his 3rd chance. Actually, he does not have a chance in the game as literally ALL 4* pikemen are better than him. Rephase, it is quite hard to build him properly (build minions? build hero?)


Thursday, September 3, 2015

MnD - Octavius skill effect (2015/09/03)

Lets talk about Octavius's active skill, Battle Morale.
Battle Morale increases Octavius's and his minions' physical damage when reducing 10% health. Does it mean the bonus damage is based on:
  • Amount of damage Octavius has taken? or
  • Current HP of Octavius?
Time to test it out.

My approach is based on the following ideas:

  • The bonus damage increases Octavius critial damage, which is a visible measurement to the Battle Morale effect
  • If damage taken is the basis of Battle Morale, healing allows Octavius to take more damage and thus have higher damage and higher critical damage as time passes
  • If current HP is the basis, healing will not benefit Octavius (but reduce his bonus damage from Battle Morale)

Testing stage
Infantry material Lv35, enemies are all pikemen with same defenses so it is certain that change in Octavius's critical damage is due to Battle Morale only.

Results
Without heal, max critical damage is 4092.
With heal from Shadown Necklace and Heal, max critical damage is 4995.

Conclusion
Since heal increases the max critical damage, it can be concluded that Battle Morale depends on damage taken.

To maximize Battle Morale effect, you can do the following:

  • Raise Octavius defense but dont give him any HP gears. With less max HP, it requires less damage taken to trigger Battle Morale.
  • Drop as many heal you can on him once he starts fighting

Wednesday, September 2, 2015

MnD - Is AoE really AoE in Mini Warriors? (2015/09/01)

AoE (Area of Effect) means something that can affect ALL units in the area. In Mini Warriors, there are 4 types of AoE in general:
1. AoE skill damage (Rains of Arrows, Firebomb etc)
2. AoE buff / debuff (Joan's Freedom Cry, Shazzo's Roaring etc)
3. AoE physical attack (Giant's attack)
4. Morale skills (Mist, Heal, Explosion)

But is it really the case in the world of MW? It is time to find out.

Let's see how many targets are hit by a Firebomb (AoE skill damage) in a lane with 4 enemy squads, each with 25 minions:
You can clearly see that not all units inside the Firebomb are damaged

So...AoE skill damage has a cap on number of targets. So what is the exact cap? Here is a test with William against a lot of enemy squads, each with 25 minions
William's AoE test result

Roughly 15 targets are hit by William's AoE. How about other AoE, like AoE debuff?
Many targets are debuffed by Raving

Takeaway
- AoE skill damage on a large group of enemies is not as effective as it seems since there is a 15 target cap.
- AoE buff / debuff works on a large group of units

(Hope you enjoy this very long post :P) 

Friday, August 28, 2015

MnD - Poor cavalry AI (2015/08/27)

The AI behavior for cavalries and mounted archers was changed to prioritize the furthest enemy in next lane if the current lane is empty.

The behaviors of these 2 classes become so predictable compared with the one before v1.8. I am kind of disappointed to this as it creates more weakness than benefits to cavalries and mounted archers.

1. Cavalries are easily countered by pikemen at the back (like what I did for my Top-Shield rally)
2. Mounted archers will charge to frontline and get rekted, as you can see below:
Nicola is in enemy's backline. Usually he dies super fast in battles...

Personally, I don't really like this change. I really hope Triniti will work on this (although I exploit this behavior and wins a lot of battles LOL).

Saturday, August 15, 2015

MnD - Special stage (2015/08/14)

Special stages were introduced in v1.8 to diversify game play. There are 4 types of special stages:

1. Gold
2. Hero xp
3. All round (with fair gold and hero xp)
4. Reward chest

I usually play 3 times the gold stages as it is one of the major source of gold WHEN it had double gold.

Guess what happened after the server update on 14th...

The hero experience and gold in the special stage has restored to normal level. Trust me, dont farm these stages for gold nor hero xp as u will get them from PvP anyway. Just do 3 times a day for the tcrystals.

Monday, August 10, 2015

MnD - Effect of dodge (2015/08/09)

Dodge is always a myth in game, whether it reduces physical damage by a fixed percentage or is a percentage chance to ignore physical damage. Time to find out.

My test subject is Alash and his squad

Approach
- Min. damage per hit: 10hp
- Total damage to Alash and squad / 10 = # hits by enemy
- If dodge is a chance to ignore damage, # hits by enemy should reduce when dodge rate increases
- If dodge is a damage reduction, # hits will not change when dodge increases since min damage is 10hp in all situation

The result is as follow:

It is ration obvious that the increase of dodge reduces damage received, which means that # hits are reduced. I  would say this suits the hypothesis that dodge is a chance to ignore damage.

One very simple prove of my hypothesis is about Mist. When Mist applies, units have increased dodge and ... they take no damages inside the mist. So it's definitely not a simple reduction.

The new hero Achilles also support this idea, stating in his skill that if an attack is missed, his next strike will not be missed. If it is a reduction, Triniti will not used the word"missed" on Achilles's skill, right?

Monday, July 27, 2015

MnD - AI Target Seeking Logic (2015/07/26)

One key note of AI change is that inter-lane fighting only happens in 2 conditions:
1. Enemies in same lane are all dead
2. Archers and mages can attack across lane

For condition 1, will AI pick upper or lower lane if both lanes have enemies with same distance?

Here is a series of tests to see the behavior of the middle Savage Infantry and Cavalry.
Same melee class: Downward
Both melee, different class: Downward
Same ranged class: Downward
Melee up, range down: Upward

So AI goes down before up. Not good for my plan to have Reinhard at the top left corner to absorb cavalries damages when I can have 19 heroes.